Custom labels for comics on eBay: a label on every comic that finds it in the box
An order comes in for an issue of Nova. It is somewhere in one of forty long boxes in the garage. The Custom label on the listing is the only thing eBay keeps that can tell you which box and where in it, and only if you put that there when you listed it. This is a labelling system that does: what the field is, the shape of a label that finds the comic, and what the label does for you after the sale.
What the Custom label is, to eBay
Every eBay listing has a field called Custom label, marked SKU. It is your reference: you set it, eBay stores it, and it comes back to you beside the listing on your active listings in Seller Hub, beside the sale on your orders, and as a column in the reports you download from there.
In a File Exchange bulk upload file the column is named
Custom label (SKU), parenthesis and all. CustomLabel
is not the name in that template, and a header with that name fails. The
eBay File Exchange template
guide has the rest of the file.
eBay does not make you give each listing a different label. My older listings carried the box number as the label, a dozen listings sharing it, and eBay took them all. That is the first thing to decide.
A label per comic, not one per box
A box number on every comic in the box is quick to type, and it does half the job: it tells you which box to pull down. It stops there.
- The order does not say which comic. Box 30 has a hundred and fifty comics in it. You find the one that sold by reading covers against the order's title.
- Nothing downstream can tell the comics apart either. A sale on another site names a label, and a label that is on twelve eBay listings cannot say which of the twelve to end. Any tool that ends listings by label either ends all twelve or none of them.
- Your own history blurs. A relisted listing gets a new eBay item number, so the item number is a poor way to follow one comic over months. A label that belongs to one comic follows it through every relist. On my own exports, counted by item number, 61% of the listings under $5 looked gone within three months; counted by label, the same rows read 30%. The difference was relisting, not selling.
A label per comic costs one extra number per listing, and every one of those three problems goes away.
The exception is a second copy of an issue you already have live, the same comic in the same shape: it goes on the live listing as more quantity, under that listing's label, filed beside the first copy. The eBay duplicate listing policy guide says why, and when a second copy needs a listing of its own.
The shape: the box, a dash, the slot
The shape that works is the box, then a dash, then the comic's place in the
box, counted from the front: 76TR-001 is the first comic in box 76 TR,
76TR-002 the second. Four habits make it hold up for years:
- The box part is letters and digits and nothing else. No
spaces, no slashes, no # sign. A label with a space in it gets torn in two by
the first tool that reads a pasted list of labels as words, and
M2 CC-004becomesM2andCC-004, which are two different things. - The slot is three digits, zero padded.
76TR-009and not76TR-9, so that sorting the labels as text puts them in shelf order, and so every label in a box is the same length. - The number is the box. If you add letters after the box
number, as I do to mark which batch a comic came in with
(
44W,44TR), keep the number the physical box, so every label that starts with 44 is in box 44. - A slot is never reused. When a comic sells, its slot stays empty. The next comic into the box takes the next number after the highest one used. A number that has been on a listing has a sale history, and a second comic under it inherits the first one's.
Put the label on the comic as well as on the listing: on a sticker on the bag, or in pencil on the back of the board. A comic pulled for photographs, or knocked out of order, then goes back in its slot by reading it, not by guessing, and the slot order in the box stays the order on eBay. The free custom label sheet prints a box's worth of these on Avery labels.
Case is the other thing to settle. 76tr-001 and
76TR-001 look like two labels to some software and like one to
you. Pick upper case and keep to it, and treat any tool that tells the two
apart with suspicion.
A pick list from the orders
Once every order carries a box and a slot, the morning's orders are a route. Download the orders from Seller Hub, sort them by the label, and you have the walk: every order in box 44 together and in slot order, then the next box. Pull, tick, move on, rather than reading one order, walking to a box, walking back, and reading the next.
One catch in the sort: as text, box 100 sorts before box 44. Sort on the box number, or pad box numbers to the same width from the start.
Ending a listing when the comic sells somewhere else
A comic that sells at a show, on Whatnot or in a shop has to come off eBay
the same day, or the next eBay buyer pays for a comic you no longer have. A
File Exchange file can end listings in bulk: an End row names the
eBay item number and a reason, and for a comic sold elsewhere the reason is
NotAvailable. The item number is what the file needs, and the label
is how you get to it: the other site's sale names 44W-014, your
active listings report says which item number wears 44W-014, and
that is the row. With a box label, that lookup comes back with twelve item
numbers and no way to choose. The same label on the other site is what makes
this work, which is why the
Whatnot guide calls its SKU
column the one never to leave blank. Keeping eBay, Whatnot, Shopify and
Discogs in step from that one label is what the
crosslisting guide
walks through.
Relabelling
Comics move. A box gets split, a run gets pulled into its own box, a dollar box gets merged into another. When a comic moves, change its label to the new box and that box's next free slot, on the live listing, the same day. The listing keeps its item number; only your reference changes. Change it anywhere else the comic is listed too, or a sale there names a label your eBay listings no longer carry. If you are moving a whole store from box labels to per-comic labels, do it a box at a time, as you go through the box, so each new label is written while the comic is in your hand.
How Point and Sell labels a comic
You name the box; it numbers the comics. Type the box label
once, on the New listings page or the Photograph with phone page. Spaces are taken out and the
slot is added: a box typed as 76 TR gives 76TR-001,
76TR-002 and on, one label per row, lots included, in review screen
order. You cannot type a single row's own label.
The numbering carries on. A batch starts after the highest
slot already used under that box label, in your live eBay listings or
in earlier batches for that box. Use the same label next month and it picks up
where it stopped. The review screen says where the batch starts, and a
Start number (under More options on the New listings page) overrides it. Case does not matter
for this: with 76TR-005 in your live eBay listings, a batch for 76 tr
starts at 76tr-006, though the label keeps the case you
typed.
Wrong box? Until the batch is approved, the review screen can change its box label, and the numbering is worked out again. After approval it cannot be changed: the labels may already be in a file you uploaded.
What the file will not carry. A label that is not letters
and digits, a dash and three digits is refused, and so is a label that appears
twice in the file. So a box runs to slot 999; slot 1000 would be
76TR-1000, which is refused, so a box that full needs a new
label.
Your older labels. A label of up to ten letters and digits,
a dash, three digits and an optional letter is read as one comic. A label of
another shape on two or more live listings is read as a box, and the Inventory
page shows each listing under it as its own comic in that box. Letters after a
box number mark a batch, not a box, so 44W-001 and
44TR-012 are both in box 44.
The pick list. The Pick list page takes the orders download
from Seller Hub, your unshipped orders straight from eBay if your account is
connected, or a pasted list of labels from a Whatnot report. It sorts by box
number, then slot. Each order gets a number, 1, 2, 3 by ship-by date, and every
line starts with that number in a big box, then the buyer's username and the
order number, so a comic pulled from box 44 goes straight on its order's pile.
After the walk, a Pack by order page (it prints on a page of its own) lists
each order's comics together with a box to tick as each goes in the package,
and marks the one-comic orders single. Labels pasted from a Whatnot report have
no buyer or order number, so they are one pile tagged W. Pasting two shows?
Put a line like Show: Friday night or W2 above each
show's labels, and each show is its own pile, tagged W1, W2. Four labels pasted in
come out as:
| Walk to | Pull, in this order |
|---|---|
| Box 44 | 44W-001, 44TR-012, 44W-014 |
| Box 71 | 71W-003 |
A label on two order lines is flagged, and an order with no label is listed at the end to find by hand. The sheet is paper: nothing is marked shipped.
The End file. In Whatnot shows, paste the labels that sold
elsewhere. Each one is matched whole against your latest active listings, and
you get an End row per listing with NotAvailable as the reason. You
download it, or, with your eBay account connected, the site sends it. A
per-comic label on two live listings ends both, with a warning. A box label on
two or more live listings is left out and named, because the file cannot tell
which comic sold: end it by hand, or run the box audit, which compares fresh
photos of the box with its live listings and gives the End file the listings
whose comics it did not find. A listing holding more than one copy is left out
too, because ending it would end the unsold copies.
Relabelled listings. When you change a live listing's label on eBay, the next read or upload of your live eBay listings matches it by item number, so its history carries over.
What it does not do: it does not relabel live listings for you, and after a batch is approved its labels are settled. It does not reuse the empty slots a sale leaves. The pick list does not mark orders shipped, and the End file only knows the listings in your latest active listings, so a newer listing is not in it.
Try it on a box · Store categories for a comic store · More guides
Sources
The 61% and 30% are from my own store's exports, counted on 26 August 2026. The box and slot shape is my own practice, not a rule.