Cross listing on Whatnot, eBay, Shopify and Discogs: how cross posting works, and the sale that has to come down everywhere
Cross listing on Whatnot, the short answer. To crosslist to Whatnot, list the item on Whatnot and on eBay under the same custom label, and when it sells on one, take it down or lower the count on the other the same day. Point and Sell has no direct link to Whatnot: Whatnot declined our request for API access, so a Whatnot sale is not read on its own. What you get is the Whatnot file for Whatnot's bulk upload from any batch, and a Whatnot sale is one tap, Sold elsewhere, on Inventory. With crosslisting on, that lowers the comic's count, and the eBay listing is lowered to match, or ended when the count reaches 0, where sending to eBay is switched on for your account; otherwise the log says what to change on eBay. How to crosslist eBay to Whatnot, step by step, is below.
Crosslisting means offering one item on more than one marketplace at once. For a reseller it is the obvious way to more buyers: the same comic on eBay and in a Whatnot show, the same record on eBay and on Discogs. It works, and it has one cost that the pitch for it leaves out. The item exists once. When it sells in one place it has to come down everywhere else before a second buyer pays for it, and a sale you cannot fill is a cancelled order, a refund and, on eBay, a mark against the account you spent years building.
So a crosslisting setup is two jobs: writing the listing for each marketplace, and taking it down on the others when it sells. Most of the advice is about the first. Most of the money is in the second.
How to cross list on Whatnot from eBay, step by step
Cross posting to Whatnot from eBay comes down to five steps:
- Give each comic its own custom label. Use the same label, like 76TR-012, on its eBay listing and its Whatnot listing. A label shared by a whole box, like 76TR, cannot say which comic sold.
- Make the Whatnot file. Point and Sell makes it from any finished batch: a show file with your opening bids and a run-of-show sheet, or a Buy It Now file. For a box already live on eBay, it makes a show file from what is still live, with the custom labels your eBay listings carry. Only comics Point and Sell listed itself go in; an eBay listing made before you used it has no batch on file and is left out, named.
- Upload it with Whatnot's own bulk upload. The Whatnot bulk upload guide goes through the file.
- When it sells on Whatnot, mark it. Whatnot declined our request for API access, so nothing reads a Whatnot sale on its own. Press Sold elsewhere on the comic in Inventory and pick Whatnot. With crosslisting on, eBay is lowered to match, or ended at 0, where sending to eBay is switched on for your account; otherwise the log says what to change on eBay. After a show with a lot of sales, paste the sold custom labels and you get the eBay End file for them.
- When it sells on eBay, take it down on Whatnot yourself. Nothing changes on Whatnot by itself. With eBay connected and its sale notices on, you get an email saying that comic is also in your Whatnot file.
None of this makes a double sale impossible. Two sales close together on two sites can still both go through, so check the log. A second road runs through a Shopify store and Whatnot's own Shopify app: moving eBay listings into Shopify, and from there to Whatnot explains it.
Pick the marketplaces where your category sells
Ten marketplaces is not ten times the buyers. Comics sell on eBay and in Whatnot's live shows. Records sell on eBay and on Discogs, where record buyers already shop by pressing. A shop with its own customers sells on its own Shopify store. Posting a long box of back issues to a clothing marketplace adds listings to manage and very few sales. Start with the two or three where your category already moves, and add one when you know it pays for the time.
The same item is a different listing on each one
eBay wants its own category and its item specifics, the fields buyers filter on; the item specifics guide covers comics. Whatnot wants an opening bid for a live show and a price for its Buy It Now store, and a show runs in an order you choose; the Whatnot guide covers the file. A Shopify product wants your store's own description, with nothing in it about eBay policies or eBay search; the Shopify guide has the columns. Discogs wants the exact release by number and a grade on its own scale; the Discogs inventory CSV guide explains why a record whose pressing is not certain stays off it. Selling the same records on eBay and Discogs, and keeping the two in step, is its own guide: Discogs eBay integration.
Copying one listing's text into four boxes is where crossposting eats the afternoon. The details are the same four times; the shape is different every time.
One custom label, everywhere
The thing that keeps an item the same item on four marketplaces is its custom label: the SKU, the box and the number, like 76TR-012. Put the same label on every listing of it, and write it on the bag. Then a sale anywhere names one physical thing, in one box, and the question "is it still listed somewhere?" has an answer you can look up. The custom labels guide has the pattern.
The sale is the part that matters
Take a sold item down everywhere else the same day, before anything else. Three habits make that possible:
- Know where each item went. A list by custom label of every marketplace an item was offered on. Without it, a sale sends you searching four sites.
- Do it in one pass. After a Whatnot show, end the eBay listing of every item that sold in the show at once, rather than one listing at a time while the next show is starting.
- Put a show first, then the store. Whatever does not sell in a live show is the natural stock for a Buy It Now listing; whatever sells is a list of labels to end elsewhere.
A quantity of more than one is the exception that needs care. If you have three copies, a sale is one fewer everywhere, not an ended listing. On eBay, identical copies at a fixed price belong on one listing with a quantity, not on a listing each; the eBay duplicate listing policy guide explains why.
How do I move my eBay listings into Shopify, and from there to Whatnot?
Connect your Shopify store and your eBay account, open the Shopify page and press Count my eBay listings. That is a dry run: it reads your live eBay listings and tells you how many would come over, and what it leaves out and why: auctions, listings with variations, blank custom labels, box labels, one comic's label on two live listings, listings with nothing left to sell or no usable price, and prices in another currency. It counts what comes over by kind, and names any listing with no custom label. Anything already in your store is skipped, so running it again makes no duplicates.
Every product gets a parcel weight, since Shopify and Whatnot price shipping from it: the eBay listing's own, else the usual parcel for a comic, book, video game, Funko Pop, record or film. Any other listing with no weight on eBay is held and named, so you can add one on eBay and count again. Make a sample first, a few listings of each kind you sell, check them in Shopify, then Start brings over the rest.
Start makes each listing that passed a draft product in your store,
the ones you listed before Point and Sell too, with its photos, price and
quantity. A comic Point and Sell identified is built as the site builds any
Shopify product; any other listing gets only what its eBay listing says, its
eBay description without the paragraphs that only make sense on eBay. Every
product is a draft on no sales channel, tagged pas-import- and
the day the run started, so one filter in Shopify reviews, activates or
deletes the whole run. Once they are made, each product also gets its eBay
item specifics as tags, and its publisher or brand as the vendor where the
vendor is blank. No AI reads anything on this road.
Box labels are the ones that catch people out. A label shared by a whole box, like 76TR, cannot say which comic sold, so those listings stay out. Each comic needs its own label, like 76TR-012, before it can come over.
The weight Point and Sell gives a Shopify product is the packed parcel, not the comic alone: a comic eBay has at 3 oz goes on as 6 oz, with its bag, board and mailer. Whatnot's Shopify app picks the Whatnot shipping band from that weight, so a comic weighed bare would land a band too low, and you would pay the difference on the label.
From Shopify to Whatnot is Whatnot's own Shopify app, not Point and Sell. You install it in your store and connect Whatnot there, and it brings your store's products into Whatnot. It takes active products only, so activate the drafts you want on Whatnot first. We have not yet run a Whatnot sale through that app on a real store, so this guide does not promise that one comes back and changes eBay by itself. Until we have, mark a Whatnot sale with one tap, Sold elsewhere, on Inventory.
How Point and Sell fits in
You photograph a box once and tick where the batch goes: eBay, a Whatnot show, a Whatnot Buy It Now store, your Shopify store, and Discogs for a crate of records. One review screen makes every file: the eBay file (or the listing itself, sent to eBay with a connected account), the Whatnot show file with your opening bids and a run-of-show sheet, the Buy It Now file, the Shopify products file with your own Shopify description, and the Discogs inventory file. Every one of them carries the same custom label.
For the sale: Crosslisting is in every plan once you turn it on in Settings: each comic has one count, a sale on eBay or your connected Shopify store lowers it, and your other connected sites are changed to match, usually within minutes, with every step in a log you can read. Whatnot and Discogs take files you upload, and one tap marks a sale made there, on HipComic or in person. eBay's quantity is changed for you where that is switched on for your account; otherwise the log says what to lower on eBay. Two sales close together on two sites can still both go through, so check the log. While a Whatnot show is on, live-show mode can show fewer copies on your other sites, so a sale that settles late cannot sell a copy twice.
With eBay connected, you also get an email naming the Whatnot, Shopify or Discogs file an eBay sale also went into. After a Whatnot show, paste the sold custom labels and you get the eBay End file for them.
What it does not do: it does not post to Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Etsy or Facebook Marketplace. It does not read sales on Whatnot or Discogs directly: mark one with one tap on Inventory, or paste the labels after a show. Apart from a Shopify store connected to the site, it does not take a listing down anywhere but eBay; the email tells you which ones to take down. Records, games, Funko Pops, movies and CDs do not go into the Shopify file. And nothing goes up anywhere until you have checked the rows and approved them.
Cross posting on Whatnot, question by question
Can you cross list on Whatnot?
Yes. Whatnot takes a bulk CSV, so the same comic can be live on eBay and in your Whatnot show or Buy It Now store at once. The Whatnot bulk listing guide covers that file. The hard part is the sale, not the listing.
How do I crosslist to Whatnot from eBay?
Make a Whatnot file and upload it with Whatnot's own bulk upload. Point and Sell makes it from any finished batch, or makes a show file from a box of what is still live on eBay, with the same custom labels your eBay listings carry. The Whatnot bulk upload guide goes through the file.
What do Whatnot's seller fees leave me, next to eBay's?
The free Whatnot fee calculator works out the payout on one sale, and eBay vs Whatnot fees puts the same sale on eBay, Whatnot and Mercari side by side, with what you keep on each, so you can see what a cross posted comic leaves you on either site.
Does Point and Sell connect to Whatnot directly?
No. We asked Whatnot for API access and Whatnot declined, so there is no direct Whatnot link today. Whatnot takes Point and Sell's files, and one tap marks a Whatnot sale.
What happens on eBay when it sells on Whatnot?
Press Sold elsewhere on the comic in Inventory, pick Whatnot and how many. The count drops once, even on a double tap. With crosslisting on, eBay is lowered to match or ended at 0, as above, and the log says what was done. After a show with a lot of sales, paste the sold custom labels instead and you get the eBay End file for them. Two sales close together on two sites can still both go through, so check the log.
What happens on Whatnot when it sells on eBay?
Nothing changes on Whatnot by itself; take it down there yourself. With eBay connected and its sale notices on, you get an email saying that comic is also in your Whatnot file, so you know to take it down there.
Can cross posting to Whatnot stop a comic selling twice?
No. With crosslisting on, one count and a log of every step make a double sale easier to catch, not impossible. A Whatnot sale reaches eBay only when you mark it with the one tap or send the eBay End file, an eBay sale reaches Whatnot only when you take it down there, and two sales close together on two sites can both go through. Take a sold comic down everywhere the same day.
Can I move my eBay listings to Shopify, and on to Whatnot?
Yes, with your Shopify store and your eBay account connected. Count my eBay listings says what would come over, and Start makes each live Buy It Now listing that passes the count a draft product. Activate the ones you want, and Whatnot's own Shopify app brings them into Whatnot. Moving eBay listings into Shopify has the details.
If you sell clothes across ten marketplaces and write your own listings, a crosslister such as Vendoo or List Perfectly fits that better. Here is how Point and Sell compares with Vendoo and with List Perfectly, and all three crosslisters side by side.