Key issues: how to spot one in a long box before you price it at a dollar
A long box can hold a comic that is not a dollar book. It looks like the others: the same bag, the same board, often the same series. Price the box at a flat rate without looking and that comic goes out at the flat rate, to the buyer who knew what it was. This is how to spot one before that happens, how to check what you have found, and what to put in the listing when it is one.
This is not a price list. What a key is worth is what copies in your comic's shape have sold for, and the pricing guide is about finding that number.
What makes a comic a key
A key is an issue collectors want for a reason beyond the story in it. The reasons repeat, and most keys have one of these:
- A first appearance. The first time a character, a team or a villain shows up. The part collectors argue about is what counts as first: a cameo of a panel or two, a full appearance and a first cover appearance can be three different issues, and they are not priced alike.
- An origin. The issue where a character's story is told, which is sometimes years after the character first appeared.
- A death, or a big change. A death, a new costume, a new identity. Plenty of these are undone later, and the issue often stays a key anyway.
- A first issue. The #1 of a series that ran and mattered. Not every #1: publishers relaunch series at #1 often, and many of those are ordinary books.
- A creator's first work, or their first on the character they became known for.
- A small print run. A late issue of a series near cancellation, or an early book from a small publisher, where not many copies were printed to begin with. This is the key that does not look like one, because nothing on the cover says so.
- A famous cover. A cover that has been copied and homaged for decades can carry demand of its own, whatever is inside.
Then there is the edition. For years many comics came in two editions of the same issue: a direct edition sold through comic shops and a newsstand edition sold everywhere else. They are usually told apart by the box in the bottom corner of the cover, where a newsstand copy carries a plain barcode and a direct copy usually carries artwork, a logo or a barcode marked for the direct market. On some books collectors pay more for the newsstand copy, and on many it makes little difference. When a key comes in both, say which one you have.
Spotting one in a box
Nobody remembers every key, and nobody has to. A pass through a box looks for signals, and each of these is worth pulling a comic out for a second look:
- The cover says so. Publishers have long printed "1st appearance", "Origin" or "Death of" on a cover when they had one to sell. Take it as a lead, not a fact: a cover blurb is advertising, and it is not always right about what came first.
- A #1. Check the year as well as the number, for the reason above.
- A character you know, looking early. A famous character in a costume that is not quite the one you know, or under another name, is sometimes an early appearance.
- Age. The older the comic, the more its price depends on things a flat box price does not see, and the less likely that price is to fit it.
- A small publisher's early issues, and a series' last few, for the print run reason above.
Pull anything that trips one of these into a short stack and check them together. It is a few minutes against a box of listings, and the stack is the part of the box where those minutes pay.
Checking what you pulled
A suspected key is checked in two steps, and the order matters.
First: is it a key, and for what? Key-issue lists and price guides answer this: the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide in print, and the price guides and key lists online. A key list usually names the reason beside the issue. Read the reason, not only the figure. "1st appearance" and "1st cameo" are different claims about different issues, and the reason is the sentence you will be putting in your listing. The free comic key issue checker looks a series and issue up in the list Point and Sell checks against, and gives its reason.
Then: what does your copy sell for? A guide's figure is a summary of a market, often for one grade, and your copy is one comic in one shape. Search eBay for the series and issue, filter to sold items, and read the grade on each sale, as the pricing guide describes. Check the year too: a series that has been relaunched can have several #1s, and only one of them is the key.
A sold search that comes back empty is not an answer of zero. It usually means the market is thin, and a thin market is where a guide's figure and a patient price do the most work.
Put the reason in the listing
A buyer hunting a key often searches for the reason. In the title it goes right after the issue number, in the words a buyer types, ahead of the words that describe every comic. The same comic, titled without its reason and then with it:
- Amazing Spider-Man #300 Comic Book Venom David Michelinie Marvel Comics 1988
- Amazing Spider-Man #300 1st Full Venom Comic Book Marvel Comics 1988
Be exact. A "1st" on an issue that holds a cameo, or on a first cover appearance, is the kind of mistake a key's buyer checks, and it can come back as a return. None of the item specifics in this site's item specifics guide is for a key, so say it again in the description, in a full sentence, with the edition and anything else that sets your copy apart.
Three more habits:
- List it on its own. In a lot, a key is averaged away with the issues around it; the lots guide covers what belongs in one.
- Photograph what the price depends on. The spine, the corners and the back cover, close enough to judge; the photography guide covers the setup.
- Think about grading the big ones. A buyer paying for a key wants to know its grade, and a slab settles the argument; the graded comics guide covers listing one. Whether grading pays for itself depends on the book and the grade, and that is a sum to do with real sold prices before you send it off.
A key is often a variant question as well: which cover, which printing, which edition. The variant covers guide covers titling those.
How Point and Sell looks for keys
A check on every batch, before it goes live. On the review screen each comic row is looked up by series, issue and year in a hand-curated list of 606 key issues across 200 series. In a lot, each issue in the Lot issues box is checked against the lot's price.
Two chips. A row is flagged only when the key's floor value is at least 3 times the row's price and at least $10 above it, so a comic at $1.00 is flagged only for a key whose floor is $11.00 or more. A flagged row carries one of two chips:
- WORTH MORE: from $N when it is sure which volume of the series your comic is, usually because the row has a year.
- CHECK THIS ONE: from $N when it is not sure, usually because the row has no year.
The N is the key's floor value: a starting point for the sold search above, not a price for your copy. Hover the chip for the reason it is a key. The same rows are listed above the table under Definitely reprice and Worth investigating, marked VERIFY VOLUME where the volume is the question.
When it knows little, it says so. When a batch has four or more series and the list knows a quarter of them or fewer, the review screen says that "no flags" means nothing was checked.
The price guide chip. A setting, on by default, puts a PRICECHARTING chip on a single comic's row: PriceCharting's current value for that issue, linked to their page. It catches the small print run books a list of famous keys misses. A row it cannot match with certainty gets no chip, and lots are not covered.
What it does not do: the chips never change a price or hold up a batch. It does not decide from a photo that a comic is a key, and it does not put a key's reason in the title: to title a key this way, type the whole title in the row's Title on eBay box. A key not on its list gets no key chip. The key check ignores the Variant box, so it does not tell a newsstand copy from a direct one, or a variant cover from the regular one. It does not check books. And the floor knows nothing about the shape of your copy.