Guides

Listing a graded comic on eBay: the label, the title, the photographs and the box

A graded comic, a slab, is a comic sealed in a hard plastic holder by a grading company, with a label on top that carries its grade. Listing one is easier than listing a raw comic in one way: the grade is printed, not argued over. It is harder in another. The buyer is paying for what is on that label, so every fact on it has to reach the listing, and the listing has to prove the slab is the one described.

What the label tells you, and where it goes

The label carries the grading company, the title and issue, the publisher and year, the grade on the ten point scale from 0.5 to 10.0, and a certification number that belongs to that one holder. A CGC label also states the page quality, "White Pages" for example, and CGC's label colour says what kind of grade it is: the blue Universal label is the ordinary one, a yellow Signature Series label means a witnessed signature, and a purple label means the comic has been restored. CBCS and PGX label their slabs their own way; the comic grades guide compares the three labels and the Overstreet scale behind them.

Where each of those goes:

  • The grader and the grade go in the title, right after the issue number. "CGC 9.8" is what a graded buyer types into the search box. Titled that way, a CGC 9.8 Amazing Spider-Man #300 reads Amazing Spider-Man #300 CGC 9.8 1st Venom Comic Book Marvel Comics 1988.
  • A restored comic says so in the title. A purple label sells at a different price from a blue one of the same grade, and a buyer who finds out from the photographs will not be pleased.
  • The certification number goes in the listing, so a buyer can look it up for themselves.
  • eBay's comic book category has item specifics for Grade, Professional Grader and Certification Number, and the first two are among the filters down the side of a search. Fill them. As with every comic item specific, the column name in a bulk file has to match eBay's exactly, or the value lands in a custom field that no filter reads.

Check the certification number before you list

CGC publishes a free certificate lookup on its website: type in the number from the label and it shows what that holder should contain. Check it against the slab in your hand before the listing goes up, and do the same with any other grader's own lookup. It takes a minute, it catches a mistyped digit before a buyer does, and if the record does not match the slab, you want to know that before anyone pays for it.

Photograph the holder, the label and the back

A slab needs fewer photographs than a raw comic and each one matters more: the front of the holder, the back, and the label close enough that the grade and the certification number can be read. Tilt the slab or the light until the glare is off the plastic; a label nobody can read is a question in your inbox. Show any scuff or crack in the holder too. The holder is not the grade, but it is what the buyer receives.

Price it by grade and by grader

A 9.8 and a 9.6 of the same book are two different items at two different prices, and so are the same grade from two different companies. Search for the book with the grader and the grade, "Amazing Spider-Man 300 CGC 9.8", and filter to sold listings, the way the pricing guide describes. Do not price a CBCS copy from CGC sales, or the other way round, until you have seen what that company's copies actually sold for.

Deciding whether a raw comic is worth sending in at all is the same search twice: sold raw copies, and sold copies at the grade you expect. The is it worth grading calculator takes both prices and a CGC tier and works out what grading adds or costs after CGC's fee, the shipping and eBay's fees on both sales.

Ship it in a box

A slab is a comic in a rigid holder, and it goes out in a box with padding, not in a bubble mailer. It is heavier and larger than the raw comic inside it, so the weight and package on the listing have to be the slab's, or the postage the buyer paid will not cover it. Weigh one packed the way you pack them. The comic shipping weight calculator shows the weight and box Point and Sell writes for a slab next to a raw comic's.

How Point and Sell handles a graded comic

You say it is graded. A slab is a row you tick graded on the review screen, the same way you tick signed. The product never decides that a comic is graded from a photograph, and it never estimates a grade.

You type the label. A graded row needs three boxes under the row's More details filled in from the label: Grader, Slab grade and Cert #. A graded row with any of the three empty is refused, and so is one with an empty price or one still at the batch's starting price: type the slab's own price. A row ticked both graded and lot is refused too.

What it writes. The grader and the grade in the title, right after the issue number, as in the example above. Three extra columns, C:Grade, C:Professional Grader and C:Certification Number. eBay takes only values from its own lists in the first two, so what you typed goes in eBay's words: a CGC 9.8 is 9.8 Near Mint/Mint and Certified Guaranty Company (CGC). eBay's grader list is CGC, CBCS, PGX and PSA. A slab from another grader, or a grade that is not on the scale, gets those two left blank, the batch page names the row, and the certification number, the title and the description still carry the label. The weight and package are 1 lb 8 oz in a 13 x 10 x 3 inch box, an estimate for a CGC holder in a graded-comic mailer, and a weight or package you type on the row wins. A setting, Graded comics ship by, sends every slab on your Parcel policy, or wherever a raw comic of the same kind would go.

Duplicates. The duplicate check never matches a slab against a raw listing of the same issue, and it never offers a slab as more quantity on a live listing: a slab is its own listing.

What it does not do: no slab listing from here has been through an eBay upload yet, so check that your first graded listing goes live with its Grade and Professional Grader filled before you send more. It does not fill eBay's separate Graded item specific. It does not read the label from the photo or look up the certification number; you type the three facts and check them. A slab takes the same eBay condition setting as your raw comics. The camera counts the same number of shots as for a raw comic, so press Next comic after the label. And there is no store category for slabs: a graded single goes to a single-comic store category by its price, unless one of your own store rules sends it elsewhere.

Try it on a box · More guides

Sources

CGC's own website, for its certificate lookup and its label types. How to photograph, price and ship a slab is common practice among comic sellers, not a rule.

See it on one of yours. Take one photo of a comic's front cover. Point and Sell shows you the eBay listing it makes, with no email and no sign-up.

Try one comic free, no email

Search help
Every answer