Comic book grades on eBay and Whatnot: the ten point scale, raw copies, slabs, and what each field takes
Comic sellers grade on one scale, from 10.0 at the top to 0.5 at the bottom, and the grading companies print it on every slab. Buyers read it, search with it and argue about it. What changes from one marketplace to the next is where the grade goes: eBay has three item specifics that are really for slabs, Whatnot has a condition ladder of its own, and a raw comic's grade ends up in words either way.
This is the scale, what each field takes, and where a raw comic's grade belongs.
The ten point scale: a grade converter
These are the grades on CGC's published scale, with what CGC writes beside each number: a name at 10.0, 9.9 and 0.5, a short code in between. The Name column is the grade in eBay's spelling, so 9.4 is NM, Near Mint. Between two grades, grade down: a buyer who gets a better book than the listing said rarely complains, and one who gets a worse one opens a case.
| Grade | CGC writes | Name | eBay Grade (slabs) | Whatnot condition (raw) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10.0 | Gem Mint | Gem Mint | 10 Gem Mint | Gem Mint |
| 9.9 | Mint | Mint | 9.9 Mint | Mint |
| 9.8 | NM/M | Near Mint/Mint | 9.8 Near Mint/Mint | Near Mint |
| 9.6 | NM+ | Near Mint+ | 9.6 Near Mint+ | Near Mint |
| 9.4 | NM | Near Mint | 9.4 Near Mint | Near Mint |
| 9.2 | NM- | Near Mint- | 9.2 Near Mint- | Near Mint |
| 9.0 | VF/NM | Very Fine/Near Mint | 9.0 Very Fine/Near Mint | Near Mint |
| 8.5 | VF+ | Very Fine+ | 8.5 Very Fine+ | Very Fine |
| 8.0 | VF | Very Fine | 8.0 Very Fine | Very Fine |
| 7.5 | VF- | Very Fine- | 7.5 Very Fine- | Very Fine |
| 7.0 | FN/VF | Fine/Very Fine | 7.0 Fine/Very Fine | Very Fine |
| 6.5 | FN+ | Fine+ | 6.5 Fine+ | Fine |
| 6.0 | FN | Fine | 6.0 Fine | Fine |
| 5.5 | FN- | Fine- | 5.5 Fine- | Fine |
| 5.0 | VG/FN | Very Good/Fine | 5.0 Very Good/Fine | Fine |
| 4.5 | VG+ | Very Good+ | 4.5 Very Good+ | Very Good |
| 4.0 | VG | Very Good | 4.0 Very Good | Very Good |
| 3.5 | VG- | Very Good- | 3.5 Very Good- | Very Good |
| 3.0 | G/VG | Good/Very Good | 3.0 Good/Very Good | Very Good |
| 2.5 | G+ | Good+ | 2.5 Good+ | Good |
| 2.0 | G | Good | 2.0 Good | Good |
| 1.8 | G- | Good- | 1.8 Good- | Good |
| 1.5 | Fa/G | Fair/Good | 1.5 Fair/Good | Fair |
| 1.0 | Fa | Fair | 1.0 Fair | Fair |
| 0.5 | Poor | Poor | 0.5 Poor | Poor |
The last two columns are what Point and Sell writes. The eBay column is what goes in eBay's Grade item specific for a slabbed comic of that grade. A raw comic gets nothing in that field (the next section says why): its grade goes into the description as you typed it, and its eBay item condition is the one you pick in Settings, the same for every grade. The Whatnot column is the condition a raw comic gets on Whatnot when its grade box holds that grade, typed as the number or as CGC's code. A slab is Graded on Whatnot, whatever its grade.
The trade also writes some of these differently from CGC: GD for Good, FR for Fair and PR for Poor, as in GD/VG and FR/GD. Both spellings are read the same way. The same numbers are on a CBCS or PGX slab; the next section says how the graders compare.
Overstreet, CGC, CBCS and PGX: one scale, different labels
The Overstreet grading guide, a book Gemstone publishes, teaches the ten point scale. CGC says its grading standard was derived from the Overstreet grading criteria, and PGX says it uses the Overstreet guide's definitions of condition. So the numbers line up: a raw comic you call VF/NM is a 9.0 on CGC's scale and in the Overstreet definitions PGX publishes, and a 9.8 is Near Mint/Mint on both.
What the slab companies add is the label, and the label is where they differ.
| Who | What it is | What the label tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Overstreet | The grading guide, a book | No label. It is the reference the grades are defined in. |
| CGC | Grades 10.0 to 0.5, with a page quality scale beside it | Blue Universal: the grade as marked. Yellow Signature Series: a signature witnessed by CGC or JSA. Green Qualified: a significant defect, described on the label. Purple Restored: repair made to look original, rated A-1 to C-5. Gold: a recognized pedigree collection. |
| CBCS | Grades on the same numbers | Blue for the standard label, yellow for a signature, witnessed or verified. CBCS moved verified signatures from red to yellow in 2020, so a red CBCS label is an older slab. |
| PGX | Overstreet's definitions, 10.0 to 0.5, plus 0.3 Incomplete and 0.1 Incomplete | A Gold Label for signed or sketched books PGX has authenticated. |
The colours do not always travel between companies. Gold is a pedigree at CGC and an authenticated signature at PGX. Read the words on the label, not just its colour, and put those words in the listing. A PGX 0.3 is below eBay's Grade list, which stops at 0.5, so Point and Sell leaves eBay's Grade and Professional Grader blank for it and the batch page names the row. Price a slab from sold copies of the same grader at the same grade, as the graded comics guide says.
On eBay, a raw comic's grade goes in words
eBay's comic book category, 259104, has an item specific
called Grade, and its list is the scale above in eBay's own spelling, from
0.5 Poor to 10 Gem Mint. Beside it sit Professional Grader, whose list is
Certified Guaranty Company (CGC), Comic Book Certification Service (CBCS), Professional Grading Experts (PGX), Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA), and Certification Number, which is free text. eBay's Taxonomy API
marks Grade and
Professional Grader as selection only (eBay takes a value from its own list
and nothing else) and all three as recommended, not required.
Those three describe a slab: a grade a company printed on a label, with a number anyone can look up. A raw comic has a grade you gave it, and the place for that is the condition description, the few lines eBay shows beside the item condition, and the start of your description. Write the grade and what you saw: "VF 8.0, light spine stress, white pages". The graded comics guide covers slabs in full.
eBay also asks for an item condition on every listing, from a short list of its own that is not a comic grade at all. Pick the one that fits, and let the grade in your words carry the detail a comic buyer reads.
On Whatnot, the ladder has ten steps
Whatnot's comic categories take one condition from a ladder of their own: Graded, Gem Mint, Mint, Near Mint, Very Fine, Fine, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor. Graded is for a slab. The rest are the scale in whole steps, with nothing between them, so a 9.0 and a 9.8 are both Near Mint there. Put the number in the description, where a buyer at a live show will read it.
How Point and Sell fits in
Nothing on the site grades a comic from its photographs. Every grade is one you state.
A raw comic. Each row on the review screen has a Grade
box. Type the grade as the number, the short code or the name, or leave it
empty to use your Default grade from Settings, which is blank on a
new account until you set one. The grade is in the first line of the listing
description as you typed it ("VF condition range."), and goes into the eBay condition
description too if your condition line in Settings has {grade}
in it (the line a new account starts with does not). It is not written into
eBay's Grade item specific. The eBay item condition is the one you pick in
Settings for every comic: Very Good (4000), Like New (2750), Good (5000), Acceptable (6000), Brand New (1000). Only Very Good has been through a
real upload from here. The Whatnot file reads the same box onto Whatnot's
ladder, as the table shows, and
Whatnot bulk listing says what else that file holds and how it goes up.
A Grade box holding something that is not a grade (a stray paste, a note like "tear on back cover") is not read as one. A setting decides what happens then: use your default grade, or write no condition sentence at all. Either way the batch page names the row, so you can type the real grade before the file goes.
A slab. Tick graded on the row and type the grader, the grade and the certification number from the label. The file then fills eBay's Grade, Professional Grader and Certification Number, in eBay's own values: a CGC 9.8 goes as 9.8 Near Mint/Mint and Certified Guaranty Company (CGC). A slab from a grader that is not on eBay's list, or with a grade that is not on the scale, gets Grade and Professional Grader left blank, the batch page says which row and why, and the certification number, the title and the description still carry the label as you typed it.
What it does not do: it does not grade, estimate or suggest a grade. It does not write eBay's Grade item specific for a raw comic. And no slab listed from here has been through a live eBay upload yet, so check the first graded listing goes live with its Grade and Professional Grader filled before you send a case of them.
Try it on a box · Is it worth grading? · More guides
Sources
The scale and what CGC writes beside each grade are from CGC's own grading scale page, read on 28 September 2026. eBay's values for Grade and Professional Grader, and whether each is required, were read from eBay's Taxonomy API for category 259104 on 27 September 2026. On 22 October 2026: CGC's label colours from CGC's labels page, and that its standard was derived from the Overstreet grading criteria from CGC's FAQ on its grades; PGX's use of the Overstreet definitions, its 0.3 Incomplete and its Gold Label from PGX's grading guide and home page; the Overstreet guide teaching the ten point system from Gemstone's page for it. CBCS's own site did not load that day, so its labels are from GoCollect's report of the red label going yellow (9 August 2020) and CRG Comics' label guide, and its scale from GoCollect's grades guide. The advice to grade down and where to write a raw grade is my own practice, not a rule.